8 Jan 2017 – Today is a black day for Soka Gakkai Malaysia. If you are a leader of SGM, you should be really ashamed of what happened. Disgrace is the word we will use to describe today. One or two days before today’s All Leaders’s Meet, many leaders who stood for justice, received phone calls informing them they were being stripped off their title and were demoted to being a member. The axe came down swift and certain. The execution was through a short phone call. No dialogue. No reasons given. You are out. Just like that.
Some of these leaders came to ALM today. They wanted an answer, they needed to hear of their demotion in person. But SGM stopped them from entering IPA. It’s not even 24 hours. In a company, there is still a 24 hour period before any separation. Not only that, how valid is a phone call to demote you? Oh, that’s right, don’t forget from a Registra of Society point of view, there are only 320 registered members in SGM. The rest of us are merely visitors to the society. So, that 24 hours rules does not matter. This has become a banana republic runs by dictators.
Just outside the IPA where the control rooms are, this WD saw her comrades on the foyer and wanted to be let out but was not allowed. She started banging on the glass doors wanting to be let out. Majority of the leaders were already inside IPA chanting, oblivious to what’s happening, or choose to be ignorant, choose to be a sheep.
There’s another group of MD, outside the foyer, blocking the demonstrators from coming in. They formed a wall and after some time, they started chanting. Not sure if they are chanting for this problem to go away or they are treating these demoted leaders as devils and so chanting to keep evil away. Maybe they are chanting for themselves. Regardless, it’s upsetting to see leaders behaving in this way.
What’s worse was that SGM called the police! Which faith organization called police against its own members? Truly shameful indeed. When the police came and found out the demonstrators were members of the same organization, they were perplexed. Don’t forget that many of these people have dedicated their whole live to Gakkai, to kosen rufu. How can SGM demote them through phone calls at night and called police on them? Inhumane!
Just outside the oak doors leading to the IPA, a YWD was being stopped from going into the meeting by two women leaders. The YWD objected that she’s still a leader and have every rights to go in. Everyone walked past her, as though she’s invisible, even though she was vocal. None of the 4 division stepped in to help! Is this the organization of humanity here? What happened to Sensei’s guidance of protecting YWD? Is this the organization working for the goal of world peace?
At about 10.30am, inside IPA, the daimoku and gongyo ended. The leaders appointment began. Many new leaders were appointed. On the Chapter and above, many existing leaders were given more responsibilities – lots of “some position cum another position”. Is it really practical to put on more duties to an already overworked leader?
What made us angry was seeing the name of one MD, with the initial FKC on the screen. He was appointed as Chapter Chief. This MD was found guilty of womanizing and yet, because he had good relationship with GD, he get to keep his position in SGM and is now appointed with higher authority! Is this the type of organization that SGM has become? Person who is guilty of misconduct are kept and promoted but person who asked questions on regarding how SGM is run were sacked! These people who were sacked have contributed their whole life for SGM and yet, the emcee announced that these sacked leaders “have bad records“, as though FKC, who was just appointed a minute ago, did not have bad records!! How contradicting and insulting to the audience intelligence!
When GD spoke at about 12pm, he shared about the greatness of Ikeda Sensei. Overhead was beautiful, high definition photos of Sensei conducting his various meetings and dialogues. GD said that many famous people gave great designations to Sensei – The Giant of the East, Ikeda Dai-Sensei, The Unprecedented Man and the Rare Mentor – Mentor for Humanity. Why is he great? 4 reasons, GD said:
1. Vast Embracing Heart – Sensei always put people at ease and make them happy and help them enjoy life.
2. His Actions – he was committed to his work and strive to be a pioneer in everything he do, to break new grounds.
3. He created Soka Gakkai Buddha
4. He established the foundation for the eternity of SGI
We could not help but wondered – how hypocrite can GD be! Outside were people being unjustly demoted and they were demonstrating. Yet, inside this protective hall, he asked us to have “Vast Embracing Heart”! How can he said this with a straight face? How can all these leaders , these 1,000 leaders inside this hall, absorbed all this with such absolute trust and Obedience???
Also, we were told that one WD chief informed the leaders who demonstrated outside that they can send 4 rep to meet with GD after ALM. This WD was very senior, so they trusted her and went to a room. But GD never turned up! Why? Did he not get the message or he has no guts to face them? Is this another of his cowardly tactics? SGM said to have dialogues. People were prepared to dialogue but the topmost leader starts to avoid. Either that, or the senior WD lied about GD wanting to meet. Regardless, top leaders did not behave properly!
As the ALM meeting comes to an end, the group of MD Great Wall formed a human wall outside IPA, diverting traffic to the left and right towards the shoes cabinets, shielding the leaders coming out from the ugly demonstrators. They were singing Gakkai songs as loud as they can to drown out any sounds.
This is the state of SGM as it is today, a tightly controlled group that creates a sense of tranquility and protection, when in reality, it is an ugly society led by a group of INHUMANE dictators. What a sad realization and a terrible day to behold.
Essential Readings (Table of Content):
- Repercussion from Johor Incident
- How Did SGM Respond?
- Questions & Answers
- Gokuyo Update (December State Rep Meeting)
- Gokuyo In-Depth Analysis
- Black Day *you are reading this*
Daylight has a Facebook Page. Please like or follow our page FB/daylight.malaysia
Please share the web link to this article at daylight.my, not copy & paste the content into WhatsApp. This is to ensure accuracy of the content. Thank you.
January 8, 2017 at 10:21 pm
It is a sad day indeed. A member’s vow when take up faith it to make this world a better place.
I have been a sympathizer of this group when their unsolicited emails flooded mine inbox. Today i made up my mind as I have seenit with my very own eyes.
I don’t see the demostrators subscribe to this and therefore nothing more to add excpet for :
If you believe what’s said here, I guess u also wil believe that Najib did receive rm2.6b of donation.
LikeLike
January 8, 2017 at 11:30 pm
Eujin,
I don’t understand what you mean , sir. Could u elaborate ?
LikeLike
January 9, 2017 at 3:39 pm
I am glad I left SGM in 1994. Now happily practicing Nichiren Shoshu Buddhism as a Hokkeko. Going Tozans regularly. Life is wonderful.
LikeLike
January 9, 2017 at 4:02 pm
Thank you Steven for your comment. While Daylight has its own reservation and viewpoints about Nichiren Shoshu doctrines in which it will not be highlighted here , we hope that everyone will continue to practice Nichiren Buddhism based on the Gosho. Best regards from Daylight.
LikeLike
January 10, 2017 at 10:20 pm
Black Day 全体干部会 – 我看到了一些很好笑,又好奇,又可笑的事情
一时兴起,大家突然非常喜欢分析事情。所以原谅我也来凑一脚吧。
2017年1月8日的全体干部会,感谢Daylight为我们分析、报导这干部会的“ 盛况“。让我们看到学会员的冲突。
当天的干部会可说是非常的混乱。看到所谓的“血淋淋的一天”。我当天就见证了事情的经过。。。
当然事情演变到了其中好多段的影像传遍了整个雪隆的干事手机里,你的第一感觉应该是心痛吧,然后
再加上daylight的分析。。。突然感觉到学会好像很有问题。然而我却有另一方的见解。为什么革职了的干部没有通知他们,让他们没有办法进入会场开会。他们没有得到起码的尊重,然后就大闹了起来。
其实我本人当时实在现场,这班被革职的干部宣称他们没有得到通知,可是这班干部突然间。。。是突然。。。我注意到一样很大疑点的动作及器材,让我觉得这是一常非常可笑又觉得很有阴谋论的事情。。。你们试着猜一猜我看到什么。。。手机。。。对。。。还有。。。
重点。。。
我看到了其中一个人拿着“录像机Camcorder”,对。。。是“Home Camcorder 家庭式的录像机”。。。
这家“录像机”就对着其中一名“干部”拍着他如何大骂学会。。。我问了我自己好久,普通。。。一般的人会不会随时都带着“录像机”通街走动啊?如果无备如来。。。如果不知道自己被革职,需要带着“录像机”出街吗?
我现在情愿相信他是位“记者”,或者他是一名“导演”。。。我情愿相信他们是无辜的。。。因为那个“录像机”出卖了他们。。。
试问谁会未卜先知。。。知道自己会没有办法进入,然后在拿起“录像机”。。。其他的请大家以“CSI”的头脑想一想。。。
你们的 “Camcorder”下次不要拿来用吧。。。因为我觉得是场闹剧。。。
Camcorder。。。 哈哈。。。
LikeLike
January 10, 2017 at 11:02 pm
Dear shi, thank you for your point of view. We were there and we heard that the group did received termination notice but it was done in less than 24 hours and via WhatsApp/phone calls. They were just frustrated due to short notice. That being said , it suggest that the group may have some time to prepare camcorder to record the incident if ever something bad were to happen.
LikeLike
January 11, 2017 at 2:53 pm
Pretty upset to see all these in-fighting among comrades. What are the ‘father’ figure of the family doing to resolve this? Instead of putting a stand and asking everyone to stop, he chose silence. In fact, I’d say that he chose to incite one side against the other. And so, this will not end. There will be more in-fighting. When we all spend so much time fighting, who is going to do shakabhuku?
LikeLike
January 16, 2017 at 2:17 pm
Being an ordinary new member to SGM, I think it’s only fair if the DG make a statement in regards to what transpired the last few days. Please remember that we the members or leaders are only human and not saints so do not be betray or be deviated to leave the same organization you all are part of since day one but instead stay to fight for what’s right and good for SGM/SGI. My personal thoughts that is. Stay united.
LikeLike
January 16, 2017 at 3:48 pm
Hi Albert,
A warm welcome to you. Welcome to SGM (since you are new to this organisation). Putting the ‘transparency issue’ aside, let me say that it is a wonderful organisation to be with when it comes to practising Nichiren Buddhism (honest statement from me).
I agree with you that we are all human beings and not saint. We, the members of SGM have been waiting for General Director to provide a statement; even better will be for him to explain as to 1) why SGM have to call the police when the members(demonstrators) were unarmed. 2) Any reason why he (general director) and the other Executive Central Committee (ECC) didn’t meet the group of people to pacify them (I believe that is the highest compassion there is when we could meet to understand pacify those who disagree with us). It has been 1 week and all we heard from SGM Top Leaders was smearing and labeling towards the demonstrators. Words such as ‘evil’, ‘anti-sensei’, ‘slanderous’ were hurled at these people during leaders meeting and private conversation. This doesn’t help and on the contrary, it makes the issue worse.
The word ‘betray’ and ‘deviate’ that you use in the above are strong. I am not too sure on what evidences that you could provide to justify the usage of that word ‘betray’ and ‘deviate’. Do let us know your views. Even if I disagree or may have differing views, I will still respect your opinion.
I truly agree with you that all of us should stay on to fight for what is right in SGM. I want to add on, fight thru proper channel and with respect. No one should leave this wonderful organisation. Stay On!
Now, all of us, SGM Top Leaders right till the grassroot leaders and members (including me) should stop speaking ill of the demonstrators; stop labelling and accusing them. We should embrace differences and practice the path of a Bodhisattva. Chant abundant daimoku before the Gohonzon and pray that Righteousness will be restored.
I am still waiting for SGM General Director to provide his response. In the Corporate world, such incident would have led the CEO to produce a statement within 24 hours. But well, SGM is a religious organisation and things can be taken light and easy. Maybe in our SGM HQ office – Lite FM is their favourite channel.
LikeLike
March 19, 2017 at 4:33 am
Couldn’t understand who give the GD the right to dismiss anyone.
The path towards Kosen Rufu should be voluntarily and joyful. It’s a natural desire to propagate the teaching out of deep gratitude for the many benefits that one have received.
LikeLike
July 24, 2017 at 2:21 am
What is this supposed “Johor Incident” – there is absolutely nothing online about this (at least in English or searchable from the U.S.). Can you please expand? It doesn’t sound like anything real, like many of these anti-SGI blogs that post no facts.
LikeLike
July 24, 2017 at 9:02 am
The Johor leaders have documentary proofs of the mishandling of funds by the Johor State Chief. They have made a few public presentations (of the proof) in the early days (back in 2014) to dialogue with SGM but failed. We were told that SGM threatened law suits against them if they showed these proof again. Normal people who is making a living cannot fight against the strong and rich machinery so that is the reason you don’t see these being written.
Besides, the point of contention has moved beyond Johor incident but to the failure of keeping peace and mishandling of the situation by the current leadership. In any other countries or organisations, such failure would have resulted in the leadership apologising and stepping down. The fact that this didn’t happen demonstrate a totalitarian regime in SGM.
LikeLike